Top Mud Sites Forum

Top Mud Sites Forum (http://www.topmudsites.com/forums/index.php)
-   Advertising for Players (http://www.topmudsites.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   The Top Mud for a reason.... (http://www.topmudsites.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2554)

vmaster218 09-07-2003 06:07 PM

A few weeks back, Achaea: Dreams of Divine Lands was surpassed as #1 mud on topmudsites.com by Magica Materia.

We won't deny it.

We freaked.

Spam flooded every private and public channel there was, it was pandemonium (a few even had their tongues divinely removed)

Now, if you'd look back on the listings, we obviously bounced back, and, noteably, pretty dang fast.

So let #1-aspiring Muds be wary...your fight is going to be tough. To get Top spot, you're going to have to want it BAD. Rally together your best! Achaea's not going anywhere without a fight.

Hersheys! (hugs n' kisses)
Achaea's Madame Butterfly

Fharron 09-07-2003 07:57 PM

Erm, you mean you actually believe being #1 is synonymous with a valued achievement? That it entails a sense of righteous accomplishment rather than the perverse satisfaction of a self-serving marketing agenda, with integrity being a mute point..

I find it disappointing to hear a proud boast made by a game that features a blatant oxymoron in its listing details.

Definition of free – unrestricted; exempt from impositions, duties or fees, hindrance, gratis.

Definition of commercial – pert to commerce; mercantile; buying and selling.

Its either completely free or it isn’t, free players can either compete on equal terms with paying players or they cannot, players either have full access to the game without hindrance or they do not. You cant have your cake and charge people to eat it.

If wanting it BAD enough means being economical with the truth or writing explanatory headers that are blatantly designed to mislead then I guess I will never want it BAD enough.

I would still like to see a separate listing for commercial muds. I still remember numerous instances of voting incentives being given to players in the past, by top rated muds. I still believe that a truthful and accurate portrayal of information would be of greater benefit to visitors and ALL supporters of the site than actively supporting a fallacy.

prof1515 09-07-2003 09:29 PM

Being #1 on TMS is like China saying, "We're the greatest nation that existed! Just look at how many people we have!"

If you believe that statement, you'll believe the first post in this string.

Personally, I too agree that free means that something is absolutely free of any commercial options. I tried Achaea last year. I wasn't as impressed as a #1 standing would seem to suggest. I've seen better on 100% free MUDs (and for that matter, I've seen better on commercial MUDs too).

That's not to say Achaea's total crap or anything. Of the 800+ MUDs I've tried over the last six years, it's easily in the Top 100. But let's be honest. TMS rankings don't necessarily indicate quality. I've seen some awesome MUDs that I've never seen make the list but were great nonetheless. Does a #1 ranking (or for that matter, any ranking) indicate quality? Not really. Popularity, perhaps, but not really quality. Just something to keep in mind.

Take care,

Jason

the_logos 09-07-2003 10:05 PM

The fact that Achaea has "won" over 25 continuous competitions indicates popularity, though it does not indicate that Achaea is the most popular mud. The most popular mud is Lineage. The most popular text mud is either Gemstone III or Dragonrealms. Quality is entirely in the eye of the beholder, of course.

--matt

the_logos 09-07-2003 10:07 PM

So I guess Google and Yahoo aren't commercial enterprises, since they are free to use? (Though, like Achaea, they charge for extra features.)

--matt

malaclypse 09-07-2003 10:53 PM

Consider going into your nearest car dealership and asking for the keys to last years model. Imagine being given this car to drive around for free, but if you wanted to upgrade to the new model, with the CD player and A/C, you'd have to pay a few bucks.  You would go around telling your friends you got a free car!

Now, how is this different from Achaea's business model? When its taken out of context of the MUD genre, one so flooded with crap free games that most decent games would not be commercially viable for their creators, I  see no significant difference with the car metaphor.

Before you go and complain that its not fair that people with money get to play more, I would like to point out a few things:
1) Money is no more fair a commodity than time, intelligence, or charisma, and those are all things that usually determine power in a MUD.
2) Don't like it don't play it. You have a vast array of free dikus to play. If you notice the significant increase in quality that tends to go with a commercial game, then unfortunately you have to wake up to the realities of the capitalist market.

- Ryan

CSmith_Fan 09-07-2003 11:26 PM


Delerak 09-07-2003 11:27 PM

I wouldn't call having players click links to vote for your mud a fight. More like a contest for the players who want to see their mud on the top 20, or as you have it stay #1. It's simply advertising. Have at it.

Tavish 09-08-2003 01:17 AM

I'm not sure what the connection between the two statements is.  Is it that all the commerical muds have offered incentives or that no free games have?  How will making a seperate list for commercial games address your problem?
I believe you would be better off accepting the information portrayed instead of creating a nonexistant fallacy.  The list ranks muds according to how many votes they have received, it has never done anything more than that no matter what people wish it to represent.

the_logos 09-08-2003 01:40 AM

[quote= (Tavish @ Sep. 08 2003,01:17)]That is exactly right. It measures precisely what it measures and nothing else.

Being ranked #1 gets us a lot of newbies so we put effort into motivating our playerbase to vote. Personally, I'd like to see other muds besides just Materia Magica up there with a lot of votes. I feel that getting people to vote benefits everyon Every mud has players that are a bit bored of it and looking for something new. Why not encourage people to get exposed to other muds (and vice versa) in the hopes that players will move from a mud they're bored of to a new mud they can play?

--matt

Jazuela 09-08-2003 08:21 AM


Hephos 09-08-2003 08:43 AM

I've always said that this "top" list would be way more interesting if the current counts of a game when the list is reset is used as a "drawback" for the next session. (Meaning the "top" voted muds will need to work harder to keep their status every month.)

At the moment it is just silly, nor is it an indication in ANY way how good a mud is, evidently. It is simply an advertisement list for the games that already have a large playerbase, which is in my opinion bad for the mud community (a free list should promote the smaller games that can't afford fancy banners all over the place). Now, i dont have anything against commercial games as im currently working on one, but still, i think the free games should have a chance to get advertisement.

pkfren 09-08-2003 09:49 AM

Just curious, how exactly does TMS determine who gets what position in the ranking of the MUDs?

It could be that, maybe, a very fantastic MUD has 1k players but those players are just too lazy to vote for the MUD and it could be ranked just in the regions of 80-100.

The same could be said of Achaea, which claims that they have over 100 players online on the average. Those 100 over players may be fanatics who may keep voting.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but TMS doesn't limit 1 vote per IP, or something, every 24 hours. A voter could click on the 'vote for this MUD' link for 10 times within an hour.

Brody 09-08-2003 10:59 AM


Maelgrim 09-08-2003 02:01 PM


the_logos 09-08-2003 02:09 PM

Oi, which mud gets 1000 votes 3 hours after the counter resets?

--matt

Delerak 09-08-2003 08:03 PM

I think it was sarcasm, logos. Or really bad math.

Maelgrim 09-09-2003 12:29 PM


Delerak 09-09-2003 12:38 PM

Yeah, that's what I thought, but with this community you never know. What's 4 times 202 again? Hehe.

-Delerak

Sereina 09-09-2003 04:40 PM

Materia Magica.
Where we mix the magical world of crass mass production with a happygolucky, carefree overpopulated pbase.
Materia Magica. Where dreams come true... In stock.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:39 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright Top Mud Sites.com 2022