[Threshold]

Here is yet another reason the 2, explicit, not wiggle-able options is better:
That seems like a slam dunk really. The text box should ADD TO the information, not be something people have to use to SUBTRACT from the misinformation and imprecise nature of the vaguely specific 4 option list.

The 4 options are totally ambiguous and multiple people have shown how easily they can be misinterpreted. That is why they are not as good as the very precise and explicit 2 options.

Providing more options at the expensive of accuracy is not a good trade off.