|10-27-2005, 10:55 PM||#1|
I've been working on the design of a game now for quite a few months, ignoring the couple years of preliminary design that wasn't directed solely at the present setting.
I have held back on actually starting coding and building of the MUD until some of the details of the world design are finalized as well as for other more personal reason (ill health). However, when the project officially begins coding/building in the next month or two, I'd planned on an 18-24 month schedule to opening. I've been told that "anything longer than six months" would result in failure and personally I disagree. I'd rather take the time to actually build a comprehensive world (even if the entire thing is not built immediately, there should be sufficient content to represent the various elements players will want to encounter and would need to encounter to maintain the setting) with the greatest degree of reasonable quality rather than rush something out that's poorly-built or ill-designed.
What's everyone's thoughts on the "six month" rule someone listed to me and my own thoughts on scheduling? I'm interested in others' thoughts on the subject.
|10-27-2005, 11:10 PM||#2|
Join Date: Apr 2003
I disagree that anything that takes longer than six months will fail. However, I think the statement reflects that if you, or your team feels like they're trying to fill an abyss with a teaspoon, there is a greater chance of disillusionment and discouragement. One way around to set short term goals, so progress can be measured.
|10-28-2005, 03:46 AM||#3|
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Mill Valley, California
"Anything longer than six months" is a silly assertion to make. If a team gives up after a paltry six months, they never had the willpower to succeed in the first place.
Graphical MUDs take years to complete, and graphical technology is far more susceptible to obselescence than text technology.
18-24 months is extremely reasonable before opening for beta testing, though it really depends on how many skilled man-hours are put in during that time.
|10-28-2005, 05:47 AM||#4|
Join Date: Apr 2002
Home MUD: God Wars II
My approach worked out as follows:
Step 1) 2 months of vague ideas, resulting in the first design draft.
Step 2) 5 months of debate, resulting a second design draft and a prototype combat system.
Step 3) 11 months of further design, debate, refinement and recruitment.
Step 4) 11 months of coding with no players.
Step 5) 9 months of coding while a closed group of players tested the engine.
Step 6) 21 months of coding while running a spinoff mud to test the engine.
Step 7) 3 months of coding while running the mud as open beta (still doing this).
The design part of step 2 worked out badly; the three of us working on the basic design all had very different ideas of what the mud should be like, and the compromise we finally settled on didn't really interest any of us. The project derailed and discussions ground to a halt - so in the end of it I created a second design document, which incorporated some ideas from the original design but which was created around what I wanted. Of course the major drawback was that the other two team members weren't very keen on it, so it ended up primarily as my pet project.
Step 3 took far longer than originally planned, once again mostly due to disagreements on the design, which became even worse the more we recruited. In the end it seemed that we'd never get out of design if someone didn't start doing some actual coding, and it took a bit of a verbal kick to finally get things going.
Step 4 was the hardest from a motivation point of view, and you can see quite a quite a few gaps in the weekly progress reports over that time. Development got easier the more the mud progressed, particularly when there were players to give feedback. However now that I'm at step 7, I'm finding myself spending a lot more of my time fixing bugs and addressing issues that were overlooked in the original design. I've also had to move development to a separate port, and whenever I'm online I find that most of my time is taken up answering questions - if I need to do some serious development I'm forced to log off the mud in order to concentrate.
I don't know how much longer step 7 will take, but I'd guess at least another year. I'm not really in any particular hurry, and the whole 'open beta' thing makes a good excuse for people who complain about balance, unfinished features, or new changes.
|Setting a Schedule - Similar Threads|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Demolition Schedule||Fern||MUD Announcements||0||01-19-2006 02:50 AM|
|Mark your schedule!||calidon||Advertising for Players||0||06-03-2005 11:14 PM|
|Price Setting Economies||xanes||Advanced MUD Concepts||14||08-18-2004 03:43 PM|
|setting up my own mud with cygwin||UnKnOwN1205||Newbie Help||3||06-27-2004 09:18 PM|
|The sun is setting..||Firefly||Advertising for Staff||0||03-26-2003 01:32 AM|